Jonathan Taylor’s Sudden Decline: What’s Behind the Colts’ Star Running Back’s Struggles?
Indianapolis Colts’ star running back Jonathan Taylor has been one of the most dominant players in the NFL this season, but his recent performance has been a far cry from his earlier exploits. Just six weeks ago, Taylor was virtually unstoppable, scoring three touchdowns and rushing for 244 yards in a thrilling overtime victory against the Atlanta Falcons. However, since then, he has struggled to replicate that form, averaging a mere 3.5 yards per carry and failing to surpass 100 yards in any of his last six games.

Taylor’s decline can be attributed to several factors, including the injury to quarterback Daniel Jones and the subsequent adjustments made by opposing defenses. With Jones out, the Colts’ passing game has become less potent, allowing defenses to focus more on stopping Taylor. Additionally, the Colts’ offensive line has been depleted by injuries, making it harder for Taylor to find running lanes. As a result, Taylor has been facing loaded boxes and more defenders in the hole, making it tougher for him to break through.
Defensive Adjustments and Injuries Take Their Toll
According to Taylor, defenses have caught on to his early-season success and have made adjustments to counter his strengths. “If you have a guy who’s going for three touchdowns and 150 yards [every week], you’re going to start tuning in and saying, ‘We can’t let that happen,'” Taylor said. The numbers bear this out, as Taylor’s yards per carry have dropped significantly since his early-season surge. In his first 10 games, Taylor averaged 5.5 yards per carry, but that number has plummeted to 3.5 yards per carry over his last six games.
Despite the challenges, Taylor remains optimistic and is focused on maximizing his runs based on the available running lanes. He acknowledges that it takes a full-team effort to execute game-breaking runs, but even when big runs don’t materialize, he believes that shorter, less-celebrated runs can still be considered successful. Veteran backup running back Ameer Abdullah agrees, pointing out that Taylor is still finding success in other areas, such as yards after contact per attempt, where he ranks second in the NFL.
A Season of High Expectations
Taylor’s early-season success created incredibly high expectations, and his recent decline has been magnified as a result. However, Taylor is taking it all in stride, recognizing that the attention and scrutiny come with being one of the best running backs in the league. “This is a good problem to have,” Taylor said. “You want people to say, ‘Hey, what is going on? Why are you not getting three touchdowns [a game]? Why are you not going for 150 yards?’ And then you start having games that a good back in the NFL would have and it’s like, ‘Hey, what is this guy doing?'”
As the Colts look to regroup and make a push for the playoffs, Taylor will be a crucial component of their offense. While his recent struggles have been a concern, his ability to adapt and find success in other areas is a testament to his skill and determination. With the right adjustments and a bit of luck, Taylor could still finish the season strong and lead the Colts to a successful postseason run.


